Hacker News

32

Show HN: The Roman Industrial Revolution that could have been (Vol 2)

Reminds me of Lest Darkness Fall[1], a 1939 novel about an archeology professor who is transported back in time to Rome under the Ostrogoths on the eve of Belisarius' invasion to reconquer Italy for the Eastern Roman Empire under Justinian.

The hero of the novel, Martin Padway, gets his start teaching Arabic numerals to a Syrian banker in Rome, and then distilling brandy. By the end of the novel he's running a newspaper and has a semaphore telegraph network set up throughout Italy. Good fun reading.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lest_Darkness_Fall

by sfRattan1772841009
I like the premise but the yellow-stained AI artwork really makes this hard to like more.
by wildzzz1772842791
Creative content should be labeled as AI generated, assisted, or AI free up front.
by LastTrain1772843998
Isn't there a massive contradiction here though, on the one hand the slave can't write on the lintel and be seen in the future proving their worlds are not connected (vol 1 page 18), on the other hand there are all these artifacts that get dug up, proving that they are. Or am I misunderstanding something?
by jacquesm1772846118
This kind of fiction is pretty popular in Russia. So there are websites and forums that discuss the kind of hand-waving needed to make the stories interesting (I recommend https://www.popadancev.net/ ).

And one thing that really stands out is that there are really not that many shortcuts. To build something like a steam engine, you need to invent advanced steelmaking, casting, advanced tooling (lathes, drills, etc.), and so on.

In general, ancient people were able to exploit the tech available to them with great efficiency.

There are some technologies that were overlooked longer than they should have, but not that many. For example, rubber could have been invented 400 years earlier. Hooke had a microscope capable of resolving micro-organisms in 1665, but the germ theory of diseases took 300 more years to develop.

by cyberax1772842144
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barbegal_aqueduct_and_mills

Albeit 2nd-3rd c. AD

Featured in Connections "Faith in Numbers" S1E04 1978

https://youtu.be/z6yL0_sDnX0

by burnt-resistor1772849553
https://acoup.blog/2022/08/26/collections-why-no-roman-indus...

Great article on why the premise doesn't make sense.

by idontwantthis1772845481
by 1772845002